Question: Assalamu alaikum. One morning something like a quarrel started between my husband and me, and my husband slapped me. When I was hurt, I said: "May Allah’s wrath fall on you if you have hit me without reason." Then he said to me in anger: "One talaq, two talaq, three talaq, go, go, I have let you go, you leave." Only my mother-in-law was present there. Then after 4–6 minutes he cried a lot, said "I made a mistake", and the two of us stayed together. Besides this, on another day my husband had also said one talaq to me. Now he is remorseful, but my father-in-law has spread the matter throughout the whole area. The local scholars here say the divorce has taken place, but in many places I hear that it has not. Now what is the correct verdict of the Shariah?
Wa ‘alaikumus-salam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu.
Respected sister Mariam, this sudden accident in your family life is extremely painful. Husbands acting with utter thoughtlessness in a moment of anger during a quarrel, and then immediately weeping in regret, has become a regular tragedy in today’s society. But the Islamic Shariah does not run on human emotions or tears; rather, it is founded on the definitive limits (hudud Allah) set by Almighty Allah.
According to the Holy Qur’an, the Sunnah, the consensus (ijma‘) of the Companions and the Tabi‘in, the Imams of the four madhhabs (the A’immah Mujtahidin), and especially the final fatwa of the Hanafi school — the fatwa given by the scholars of your area is 100% correct and in accordance with the Qur’an and Sunnah. Through the words pronounced by your husband, all three talaqs (talaq mughallazah, the final separation) have fallen upon you, and your marriage bond has been completely severed. Below is an evidence-based and detailed analysis of every aspect of your case:
Your husband said in clear words: “One talaq, two talaq, three talaq, go, go, I have let you go, you leave.” Not only that, you have mentioned that on another day he had also given you one talaq.
In the Islamic Shariah, pronouncing three talaqs together is a grave sin (talaq bid‘i). But if someone commits this sin and pronounces three talaqs together, then by the consensus (ijma‘) of the Companions, the Tabi‘in, the righteous predecessors (Salaf), and all the Imams of the four madhhabs — Imam Abu Hanifa, Imam Malik, Imam al-Shafi‘i and Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal (may Allah have mercy on them) — all three talaqs fall, and the wife becomes completely unlawful (haram) for the husband.
Definitive evidence from the Holy Qur’an and Hadith:
Almighty Allah says in the Holy Qur’an:
Meaning: "Divorce (that may be revoked) is twice. Then either keep her in an honourable manner or release her with kindness... And if the husband divorces her (a third time), she is no longer lawful for him until she marries another husband."
— (Surah al-Baqarah, verses 229–230)It is narrated in the hadith of Sahih al-Bukhari and Sunan al-Nasa’i that in the time of the Messenger of Allah (صلى الله عليه وسلم), when a man gave his wife three talaqs together, the Prophet (ﷺ) stood up in intense anger and said: «أَيُلْعَبُ بِكِتَابِ اللَّهِ وَأَنَا بَيْنَ أَظْهُرِكُمْ» (Is the Book of Allah being played with while I am still among you?) — Then, in the era of the Companions, all the Companions, including ‘Umar al-Faruq (RA), ‘Uthman (RA), ‘Ali (RA), ‘Abdullah ibn ‘Abbas (RA) and ‘Abdullah ibn Mas‘ud (RA), reached consensus (ijma‘) on enforcing three talaqs given in one sitting as ‘three talaqs’.
In the foremost works of the Hanafi school, ‘Al-Hidayah’ and ‘Fatawa Alamgiri’, it is stated clearly:
Translation: "If someone gives his wife three talaqs within the same period of purity (in the same sitting), in one sentence or in separate sentences (for example, saying one talaq, two talaq, three talaq), all three talaqs fall, and he is sinful for divorcing in this manner."
— (Al-Hidayah: 2/355, Kitab al-Talaq; Bada’i‘ al-Sana’i‘: 3/94; Fatawa Alamgiri: 1/349)Many think that a divorce given in anger does not take effect — this is a completely wrong idea. Ordinary people do not divorce their wives in a happy mood; they divorce in quarrels and in anger.
According to the definitive principle of Hanafi fiqh, only that divorce in anger is ineffective when, from the intensity of anger, a person becomes ‘madhush’ (المدهوش), i.e. completely insane and devoid of awareness — meaning he has not the slightest awareness of what he is saying to whom. But look at your husband’s behaviour:
A person who, just 4 minutes after speaking, can clearly recall what he said and weeps over his mistake was never ‘madhush’ or insane; rather, he divorced consciously in a fit of intense anger. And in the Shariah, once three talaqs have left the mouth, even if one weeps a thousand times or says "I made a mistake", the talaq that has fallen never returns.
Translation: "The divorce of every sane and adult husband takes effect... even if he is in a state of anger, as long as his anger does not reach the extreme level of derangement (dahash) in which he himself does not know what he is saying."
— (Radd al-Muhtar or Fatawa Shami: 3/244; Fatawa Alamgiri: 1/353)You mentioned that at the time of the divorce only your mother-in-law was there. It is essential to know that in the Islamic Shariah, two witnesses are a condition for a marriage (nikah) to take place, but no witness is needed for a divorce to fall. Even if the husband pronounces talaq alone in a closed room, over the phone, or only in front of his wife or mother-in-law, the divorce takes effect immediately.
Translation: "By the consensus of all the Imams (according to ijma‘), having witnesses is not a condition for a divorce to take effect."
— (Al-Bahr al-Ra’iq: 3/255; Fatawa Shami: 3/230)You said, "The local scholars here say the divorce has taken place, but in many places I hear that it has not."
Respected sister, in the present age some people on the internet or in society (who follow none of the four madhhabs) deceive ordinary people by saying that "a divorce given in anger does not happen" or that "three talaqs given together count as one".
Firstly: In the 1400-year history of the Ummah of Muhammad, adopting such an isolated (shadh) opinion against the ijma‘ of the Rightly Guided Caliphs, the Companions and the Imams of the four madhhabs is completely haram. The definitive principle of fiqh is that if one adopts a fatwa contrary to the Qur’an, Sunnah and ijma‘ for one’s own convenience or out of the desire to save the marriage, it will not be accepted by Allah, and that married life will be counted for life as ‘zina’ (fornication) .
Secondly: In your case there is not even room for that debate! Because your husband had previously, on another day, given you ‘one talaq’ , and in this incident he first said ‘one talaq, two talaq, three talaq’ and along with that he also said ‘go, go, I have let you go, you leave’! So whichever way it is counted, all 3 talaqs have been finally completed upon you.
However difficult it may be, in order to be saved from the eternal punishment of the Hereafter and the sin of fornication, it is now obligatory (fard) for you to follow the instructions below to the letter:
Institutional Disclaimer: This Shariah solution has been provided in the light of the Qur’an, the Sunnah and Hanafi fiqh, based on the information supplied by the questioner. It is intended solely as religious guidance and for deeds relating to the Hereafter; it may not be used as evidence in any state court or legal dispute.
May Allah the Exalted grant you the ability to be patient in this difficult trial and to remain steadfast upon the rulings of the Shariah. (Ameen) And Allah knows best.
WhatsApp us