Islamic Q&A – Reselling Business and an Analysis of the Binnoria Town Fatwa
بِسْمِ اللَّهِ الرَّحْمَنِ الرَّحِيم
Department of Fatwa & Masāʾil

Reconciling Our Fatwa on the Reseller Business With the Fatwa of Jāmiʿah Binnoria Town, and a Fiqh Analysis

Questioner: Sadek Khan

Question: The fatwa you gave about the reseller business does not seem to match the fatwa issued by Binnoria Town (Karachi, Pakistan — Fatwa no. 144108201303). It says: after a company fixes a product’s price at 100 taka, the reseller adds 30 taka and advertises it at 130 taka; the company sends the product directly to the buyer, collects 130 taka and sends the reseller 30 taka. The Binnoria Town fatwa mentions two methods for this: (a) selling the product before buying it from the company and bringing it into one’s possession — which is not permissible; (b) working as a commission agent between the company and the buyer — which is valid subject to seven conditions; and they wrote: “The transaction contracts carried out through the above-mentioned applications are generally of this kind.” [Source: al-Durr al-Mukhtār and Ḥāshiyat Ibn ʿĀbidīn 6/63]. I would like a clear explanation from you on this.

Wa ʿalaykum as-salām wa raḥmatullāhi wa barakātuh.

Respected brother Sadek Khan, we sincerely commend your deep interest in religious knowledge and your effort to verify the matter by bringing forward the fatwa of the world-renowned fatwa institution ‘Jāmiʿat al-ʿUlūm al-Islāmiyyah, ʿAllāmah Binnoria Town, Karachi’.

The very pleasing fact, however, is that —there is not the slightest contradiction or inconsistency between the fatwa we gave on your earlier question and the Jāmiʿah Binnoria Town fatwa you have quoted; rather, both fatwas state exactly the same conclusion on the basis of the same fiqh evidence! Perhaps the linguistic structure of the Binnoria Town fatwa created some slight ambiguity in your understanding. Below we make the matter crystal clear, with the original Binnoria Town fatwa, the reports of the Companions, and the original Arabic text of the foremost Hanafi work, Fatāwā Shāmī (6/63):

1. What Does the Jāmiʿah Binnoria Town Fatwa Actually Say?

Binnoria Town classified these reselling apps under method ‘b’ (a lawful commission agent)

Look again carefully at these two lines in the middle of the Binnoria Town translation you presented:

“In the second method (b) — i.e., encouraging the customer to buy from a particular website and preparing him to do so — taking a commission will be valid subject to the following conditions. The transaction contracts carried out through the above-mentioned applications are generally of this kind.”

Notice! Jāmiʿah Binnoria Town first described in the question the reselling apps (such as Meesho, GlowRoad, etc., where 30 taka is added to a 100-taka product and it is sold for 130 taka). Then, to explain the fiqh principle, it set out two possible forms (a and b), and in its final verdict it stated clearly that — the transactions of these applications are generally of the second kind (i.e., method ‘b’ — as a commission agent or simsār), and are entirely valid subject to seven ordinary Shariah conditions!

And in answer to your first question we said exactly the same thing — that the resellers at the company where your brother works are essentially acting as ‘brokers’ (سمسار) or ‘commission agents’ (وكيل بالأجرة), and so it is halal!

2. The Evidence for Adding 30 Taka to a 100-Taka Product and Selling It for 130 Taka (the Companions and Fatāwā Shāmī 6/63)

Many may ask: the company set the price at 100 taka, and the reseller of his own accord added 30 taka and found a customer at 130 taka — is it permissible to take the extra amount as commission in this way? Yes — according to the Companions, the Successors and the fatwa of the Hanafi school, this is entirely permissible as ‘simsarah’ (brokerage).

The fatwa of the Companion Ibn ʿAbbās (may Allah be pleased with him) and of the Successors:

وَقَالَ ابْنُ عَبَّاسٍ رَضِيَ اللَّهُ عَنْهُمَا: «لَا بَأْسَ أَنْ يَقُولَ: بِعْ هَذَا الثَّوْبَ، فَمَا زَادَ عَلَى كَذَا وَكَذَا فَهُوَ لَكَ»، وَقَالَ ابْنُ سِيرِينَ: «إِذَا قَالَ: بِعْهُ بِكَذَا، فَمَا كَانَ مِنْ رِبْحٍ فَهُوَ لَكَ، أَوْ بَيْنِي وَبَيْنَكَ، فَلَا بَأْسَ بِهِ»

Imam al-Bukhārī (may Allah have mercy on him) reports in his Ṣaḥīḥ that the foremost of the exegetes, ʿAbdullāh ibn ʿAbbās (may Allah be pleased with him), said: “There is no harm if someone says to another, ‘Sell this garment, and whatever you sell it for above such-and-such a price (e.g., 100 taka) is yours (as commission)’ — it is entirely permissible.” The renowned Successor Imam Ibn Sīrīn (may Allah have mercy on him) said: “If he says, ‘Sell it for such-and-such; whatever profit there is above that is yours, or is to be shared between me and you,’ there is no harm in it.”

— (Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī, Kitāb al-Ijārah, Bāb Ajr al-Samsarah: 2/795; Muṣannaf ʿAbd al-Razzāq: 8/235)

The original Arabic text and the key point of ‘Fatāwā Shāmī (6/63)’ cited by Binnoria Town:

At the very bottom of the Binnoria Town fatwa you provided, the source is given: [al-Durr al-Mukhtār and Ḥāshiyat Ibn ʿĀbidīn 6/63]. Let us see what ʿAllāmah Ibn ʿĀbidīn al-Shāmī al-Ḥanafī (may Allah have mercy on him) wrote on page 63 of that sixth volume:

مَطْلَبٌ فِي أُجْرَةِ الدَّلَّالِ: ... وَفِي الْحَاوِي: سُئِلَ مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ سَلَمَةَ عَنْ أُجْرَةِ السِّمْسَارِ، فَقَالَ: أَرْجُو أَنَّهُ لَا بَأْسَ بِهِ وَإِنْ كَانَ فِي الْأَصْلِ فَاسِدًا لِكَثْرَةِ التَّعَامُلِ، وَكَثِيرٌ مِنْ هَذَا غَيْرُ جَائِزٍ، فَجَوَّزُوهُ لِحَاجَةِ النَّاسِ إِلَيْهِ

Translation: “(On the wage of a broker or commission agent): In al-Ḥāwī it is stated that Imam Muḥammad ibn Salamah (may Allah have mercy on him) was asked about the wage of a simsār (commission agent), and he said: ‘I hope there is no harm in it.’ Although by strict analogy it should have been invalid (fāsid) (because the wage or the duration of the work is indeterminate), the jurists declared it permissible because of widespread practice (taʿāmul/ʿurf) and people’s need for it.”

— (Radd al-Muḥtār ʿalā al-Durr al-Mukhtār [Fatāwā Shāmī]: 6/63, Kitāb al-Ijārah)

It is thus proven that Binnoria Town, on the evidence of this very page 6/63 of Fatāwā Shāmī, issued a fatwa declaring the resellers’ 30-taka profit halal as ‘ujrat al-simsār’ (the lawful wage of a commission agent) !

3. So What Is the Essential Difference Between Methods ‘a’ and ‘b’? (Comparison With Another Fatwa on Our Website)

The positions of Binnoria Town and of our fatwa department are very clear. Reselling or dropshipping can take two forms:

  • The prohibited form (method ‘a’): If the reseller claims to be the ‘independent owner’ of the product and concludes the final sale with the customer, and if, when a delivery is returned, the company forcibly collects the delivery charge from the reseller as a penalty (as was the case in the question of another questioner, Mr. Muh. Tahmid, on our website) — then it is impermissible, because of selling goods before taking possession and because of an invalid condition.
  • The permissible form (method ‘b’): If the reseller, as a listed marketing agent or representative of the company, promotes the product, collects orders and enters them into the company’s system, and the company delivers the product on its own responsibility and pays the reseller his fixed margin (30 taka) — then, because it is ‘simsarah’ (brokerage / commission agency) , it is entirely halal. The seven conditions Binnoria Town laid down (that the product be halal, that one not lie, that adverts not use music or images of living beings, etc.) are general conditions of any halal business.

4. The Final and Conclusive Ruling on Your Brother’s Job

Dear brother Sadek Khan, your first question was about the job of your brother, who at the main company does the work of photographing products, packaging, stocking and dispatching parcels .

In light of the Binnoria Town fatwa and Fatāwā Shāmī, it is 100% established that the business model of that company (according to method ‘b’) is fundamentally lawful. And even if we assume for the sake of argument that, out of the company’s 1,000 resellers, two to four individually violate some Shariah condition while promoting (for example, by falsely praising a product or making videos with music), the burden of that sin falls on those particular resellers — not on your brother, nor on the company’s halal products. The definitive principle of the Holy Qur’an is:

وَلَا تَزِرُ وَازِرَةٌ وِزْرَ أُخْرَىٰ

“No bearer of burdens shall bear the burden of another.”

— (Sūrat al-Anʿām, verse 164)

Your brother is not party to any impermissible act; he is stocking and packaging lawful products, which in the eyes of Hanafi fiqh is a pure ‘ijārah ṣaḥīḥah’ (a valid contract of employment).

Summary

  1. Our previous fatwa and the Jāmiʿah Binnoria Town fatwa (no. 144108201303) are completely one and the same. Both fatwas declare the activity of reselling apps permissible as ‘commission agency’ (method ‘b’).
  2. Taking orders at 130 taka by adding 30 taka to a 100-taka product is permissible according to the fatwa of Ibn ʿAbbās (may Allah be pleased with him) and the ‘simsarah’ (brokerage) principle of Fatāwā Shāmī (6/63).
  3. Your brother’s packaging and stocking job, the salary he earns, and any business done with that salary are 100% halal and pure. There is no room to keep even the slightest doubt or waswasah about this in your heart.

May Allah the Exalted keep you and your family steadfast upon beneficial knowledge and halal provision. (Āmīn) And Allah the Exalted knows best.