Question: Assalāmu ʿalaykum. I read your earlier post. There is one point about which I am still in doubt. Here the profit rate is not fixed; it pays profit at different rates at different times. So if it is not fixed, how can it fall under interest? Someone told me to ask the question this way: “My friends and I earn from SNAI. You must deposit a minimum of 1,250 taka and buy an NFT. After 5 days it pays profit at varying rates. In 40 days the money almost doubles. If you refer 8 people you get a 12% commission and a monthly salary. Many ʿulamāʾ are involved in it and no one has been cheated.” Now please give a fatwa: is this income halal?
Wa ʿalaykum as-salām wa raḥmatullāhi wa barakātuh.
Respected brother Maruf Ahmed, we respect your inquiry and the cleverness of the person who taught you to re-ask the question by rearranging its wording. But there is one inescapable truth we must all remember —the definitive rulings of the Islamic Shariah never change because of verbal tricks, rephrased sentences or anyone’s arguments. Even if heaven and earth were turned upside down to make the haram halal, the truth would remain firm in its place. Below, with great care, is a documented and clear refutation of your new argument by the standard of the Qur’an, the Sunnah and Hanafi fiqh:
Whoever explained to you that “if it is not fixed, it is not interest” has bypassed a very major principle of Islamic fiqh (fiqh al-buyūʿ). In Islam, the first and foremost condition of a halal business (muḍārabah or partnership) is the ‘risk of loss’ being present.
If it is such that your capital (1,250 taka or more) is 100% protected — you will never lose the capital, you will only receive profit (sometimes 5 taka, sometimes 10 taka) — then in the Islamic Shariah this is not a business at all; it is directly a loan (qarḍ). And any additional money received against a loan is ‘ribā’ (interest), whether fixed or variable.
The famous fiqh maxim: “Every loan that draws a benefit is ribā.”
— (Sunan al-Bayhaqī: 5/349; Fatāwā Shāmī: 5/166)The principle of halal business in Islamic economics is:
“The right to profit is tied to bearing the risk.” (Sunan Abī Dāwūd: 3510)
Since on the SNAI sites there is no business risk of your capital decreasing or becoming zero, and the money inevitably almost doubles in 40 days, then however many times its profit fluctuates between 5% and 12%, it is a pure interest-based dealing. A variable profit rate is merely an eyewash to make interest look halal.
In the Islamic Shariah, for a sale to be valid, the goods must actually exist and the buyer must have full ‘qabḍ’ (possession). The so-called NFTs bought on these sites have no real utility, and you cannot freely sell them on any other platform outside that site. It is essentially a staged drama for dealing in interest, which in the language of fiqh is called ‘bayʿ al-ʿīnah’ (بيع العينة) — a trap of interest in the garb of halal . The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) strictly forbade such deceptive transactions. (Sunan Abī Dāwūd: 3462)
The lure of a 12% commission on the income of 8 referred people and a monthly salary from the company is the classic form of multi-level marketing (MLM) and a Ponzi scheme. Earning commissions in a chain system based on other people’s investments and interest income is entirely haram in the Shariah. It is a direct violation of this verse of the Noble Qur’an:
“And do not consume one another’s wealth unjustly.” (Sūrat al-Baqarah: 188)
In Islam, the criterion for something being halal or haram is not any individual’s practice or the involvement of religious figures. The sole criterion of the Shariah is the definitive ruling of Allah and His Messenger (ﷺ). There is a historic and immortal saying of ʿAlī (may Allah be pleased with him):
“Truth is not known by people; rather, know the truth and you will know its people.”
“No one has been cheated” or “it pays out properly” is not evidence of a business’s legitimacy. The world’s big interest-based banks and casinos also pay their customers properly — but that does not make interest and gambling halal.
Dear brother, in no halal business in the world does money magically double in 40 days. This is an international Ponzi scheme and an interest-based MLM ring. There is no way whatsoever to make this haram halal with the argument that the profit is variable.
Investing in, working for, or referring others to SNAI and all similar platforms — and any kind of income obtained from them — is completely haram in the Islamic Shariah.
We very humbly request you and your friends: do not try to find halal within haram; out of fear of Allah, turn back from this path. Whoever abandons the haram out of fear of Allah, Allah grants him halal provision better than it.
And Allah the Exalted knows best.
WhatsApp us