Question: My brother works at a reseller company. The company has over 1,000 resellers. The company provides pictures of products, and the resellers sell them online (e.g., adding a 30 taka profit to a 100 taka product and selling it for 130 taka). When someone buys a product, the company sends the parcel directly to the buyer, collects the 130 taka, and gives the reseller his 30 taka profit.
In this company my brother is employed in photographing products, packaging, stocking products and dispatching them. My question is: is the salary he has received from this company all this time entirely haram? And he has invested the salary money in a business — if this whole salary is haram, what is the way to be saved from it? I would benefit from a detailed answer. Jazākallāh khayr.
Wa ʿalaykum as-salām wa raḥmatullāhi wa barakātuh.
Respected brother Sadek Khan, the caution that you and your brother show regarding halal earnings is most commendable. Shayṭān often creates doubts and waswasah in people’s minds even about halal matters. Alḥamdulillāh, your brother’s job and the salary he earned are entirely halal and pure. The business done with this salary is also entirely halal. There is no reason here for it to be haram. The matter is clarified below in light of the Qur’an, hadith and Hanafi fiqh:
In Islamic fiqh, the ruling on employment is called ‘ijārah’ (الإجارة) . For a person’s salary to be halal there are two conditions: first, the work he does must be halal; second, the main business of the company must be halal.
Your brother does the work of photographing products, packaging, stocking and sending them by courier at the company. Each of these tasks is entirely permissible (mubāḥ) and halal labour in the Islamic Shariah. And the company sells real, physical products; it does not engage in interest-based dealings or sell haram items. Therefore, the remuneration received for halal work in a halal company is 100% halal.
A fiqh principle: “Wages received through a valid contract (of work) are entirely halal and a rightful entitlement.”
— (al-Hidāyah: 3/230)Perhaps the doubt in your mind arose from the resellers’ business model, which in modern terms is called ‘dropshipping’. In the Shariah, selling something one does not own is forbidden (لا تبع ما ليس عندك). However, in the model you describe, the resellers are essentially acting as ‘brokers’ (سمسار) or ‘representatives of the company’ (وكيل) .
Imam al-Bukhārī (may Allah have mercy on him) cites the fatwa of Ibn Sīrīn (may Allah have mercy on him): “It is permissible for a broker or representative to take a specified remuneration (or margin).”
— (Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī, Kitāb al-Ijārah)Here the actual product remains in the company’s ownership, and the company itself is sending it to the customer under its own responsibility. The reseller merely receives a fixed commission (e.g., 30 taka) in return for finding the customer. In the terminology of Islamic fiqh this is ‘wakālah bi al-ujrah’ (الوكالة بالأجرة) , i.e., representation in return for remuneration, which is an entirely permissible and halal business method.
Since the main company’s business is halal, the resellers’ commission system is halal as wakālah, and above all your brother’s own labour (packaging, photography) is entirely halal, therefore of the salary he received, not a single taka is haram.
In the business he has started with this halal money, there is Allah’s boundless mercy and barakah. There is no need to rid yourselves of this money or give it away. You may continue this business with peace of mind.
May Allah the Exalted grant barakah to your earnings and business. (Āmīn)
WhatsApp us