Question: Respected Mufti Sahib, at one point during a quarrel with his wife, a man wrote a kināyah (allusive) sentence in a message: “Go look for some other guy.” At that time the intention/thought kept coming to his mind that “there will be a separation because of saying this sentence.”
Several points are certain in this matter:
1. The intention did not include any number such as two or three; there was only a thought of a general separation.
2. The intention kept coming to mind again and again (there is no count of how many times).
3. The man wrote the said kināyah sentence in the message only once.
Questions to the respected scholar:
1. If no number is mentioned in the intention and thoughts of separation come to mind repeatedly, is there any possibility of more than one separation because the kināyah sentence was written once? How many separations have occurred here?
2. Does the number of separations increase because the same intention comes to mind again and again?
3. If, after an intention of separation without a number keeps circling in the mind, the kināyah sentence is written only once, how many separations will count according to the Shariah?
Please relieve us of our anxiety with the correct solution.
Wa ʿalaykum as-salām wa raḥmatullāhi wa barakātuh.
Respected brother, your question is a very important and subtle masʾalah of Islamic fiqh. Alḥamdulillāh, we have analysed the situation you describe in depth. Below is a detailed Shariah solution, to free you from anxiety, in light of the Qur’an, hadith, fiqh principles and the explicit texts of the mujtahid imams of the Hanafi madhhab:
In the Islamic Shariah, uttering verbally and sending in writing carry the same ruling. According to the fiqh maxims (al-qawāʿid al-fiqhiyyah):
“Writing is like (effective as) speaking in direct address.”
— (Fatāwā Shāmī: 3/246)You wrote in the message, “Go look for some other guy.” This is not an explicit word of talaq; rather, it is an ambiguous or ‘kināyah’ expression. The settled position of the Hanafi madhhab is that for talaq to fall through a kināyah expression, the ‘intention of talaq or separation’ is a condition. Since you had the intention of separation, talaq has fallen.
No, the number of talaqs does not increase because of thoughts in the mind. The ruling of the Shariah is that a judgement applies on the basis of action or utterance, not merely on the imaginings of the mind.
The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: “Indeed, Allah the Exalted has pardoned my Ummah for the imaginings and waswasah of their minds, so long as they do not act upon it or speak it.”
— (Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī, Hadith no. 5269)You wrote the sentence only once . Even if thoughts of talaq or separation came to your mind a thousand times, since the act (writing) occurred only once, only one talaq will fall. Repetition in the mind does not multiply a physical act.
The fatwa of the Hanafi madhhab:
If talaq is intended through a kināyah (ambiguous) expression, and the intention contains no specific number (e.g., 3), then it results in 1 ṭalāq bāʾin (الطلاق البائن) falling.
ʿAllāmah Ibn ʿĀbidīn (may Allah have mercy on him) states in Fatāwā Shāmī: “If one intends talaq with a kināyah expression, one ṭalāq bāʾin falls; and if one intends three, then three fall.”
— (Radd al-Muḥtār / Fatāwā Shāmī: 3/297; Fatāwā ʿĀlamgīrī: 1/374)Since your intention contained no number and was only a general intention of separation, here only 1 ṭalāq bāʾin has fallen. There is no possibility whatsoever of more than one talaq.
And Allah the Exalted knows best.
WhatsApp us