The Sharʿī Ruling on an Intersex Person (Khunthā) Leading Men and Women in Prayer

Islami Sharia Logo
مركز الفقه الإسلامي بنغلاديش
Markazul Fiqh Al-Islami Bangladesh
Markajul Fiqh Al-Islami Bangladesh
Painadi (Donu Haji Road), Mizmizi, Siddhirganj, Narayanganj-1430
Mobile: 01917-655804, 01739-176976
Date: 26-11-1437 AH Reference No.: F-030 (Album-1)
Question (Istiftāʾ)

To: The Respected Chief Mufti (may his blessings endure)

Subject: Regarding the ruling on an intersex person (khunthā) leading the prayer.

Problem: An ʿālim in our village said that it is permissible for both men and women to follow an intersex person (khunthā) in prayer, and this has created doubt in people’s minds.

Query: What I wish to know from the respected Chief Mufti is: is it permissible for both men and women to pray behind an intersex person? Kindly inform me with evidence. May Allah the Exalted help you.

— Submitted by: Muh. Ataullah, Barura, Cumilla.
Answer (al-Jawāb)

Solution: The imamate of the intersex person (khunthā mushkil) described in the question is permissible only for women, on condition that he stands in front of the women; if he stands among the women, the prayer becomes invalid (fāsid).

References and Evidence (الأدلة الفقهية)

1. al-Durr al-Mukhtār (2/577): "لا يصح اقتداء رجل بامرأة وخنثى"
2. al-Fatāwā al-Hindiyyah (1/143): "وامامة الخنثى المشكل للنساء جائزة ان تقدمهن وان قام وسطهن فسدت صلاته لوجود المحاذاة ان كان الامام رجلاً"
3. Marāqī al-Falāḥ (p. 288): "(والذكورة) خرج به المرأة بالامر بتأخير هن والخنثى إمرأة فلا يقتدي به غيرها"
4. al-Fatāwā al-Sirājiyyah (p. 98): "امامة الخنثى المشكل لمثله لا تجوز بنية امامة النساء شرط - ونية امامة الرجال ليست بشرط"
5. Ghunyat al-Mustamlī (p. 516): "وبناء على هذا اقتداء الخنثى المشكل بخنثى مشكل لاحتمال ان المقتدي رجل والامام امرأة"
6. Kitāb al-Fatāwā (2/324): "اگر کوئی شخص خلقی اعتبار سے مخنث ہو تو مردوں کا امام نہیں ہو سکتا اور نکاح پڑھانے کی ذمہ داری بھی اسے سپرد کرنا درست نہیں"
7. Fatāwā Ḥaqqāniyyah (3/133): "اگر کوئی شخص علم فضل و کمال کے لحاظ سے سب سے بہتر ہی کیوں نہ ہو ۔ لیکن جنس کے لحاظ سے خنثی مشکل ہو تو اس کی اقتداء ناجائز ہے"
8. Others:

Ḥāshiyat al-Ṭaḥṭāwī (p. 288), Radd al-Muḥtār (2/577), Khulāṣat al-Fatāwā (1/147), al-Fatāwā al-Tātārkhāniyyah (2/258).

Islami Sharia Organization

A trusted institution for all fatwas, masāʾil and questions and answers online

Ask a new fatwa question

View other fatwas

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *