
Whoever wishes to research bidʿah (religious innovation) should consult the following books:
Anyone who wants a clear Sharʿī verdict — grounded in the evidence of the Qurʾān, the Sunnah, fiqh and uṣūl al-fiqh — on what is Sunnah and what is bidʿah in these matters, whether to learn it or to act on it, can read the following four books:
Itqān al-Ṣanʿah fī Taḥqīq Maʿnā al-Bidʿah (Perfecting the Craft: Establishing the Meaning of Bidʿah)
Ḥusn al-Tafahhum wa al-Dark fī Masʾalat al-Tark (Sound Understanding of the Question of the Prophet’s Omissions)
Both are by the twentieth-century ḥadīth master and mujtahid jurist-theorist, Imām ʿAbdullāh ibn al-Ṣiddīq al-Ghumārī of Morocco,
and both are included in the 18-volume “Encyclopaedia of Imām ʿAbdullāh ibn al-Ṣiddīq al-Ghumārī”.
Al-Bidʿah al-Maḥmūdah wa al-Bidʿah al-Iḍāfiyyah bayn al-Mujīzīn wa al-Māniʿīn (Praiseworthy Innovation and Relative Innovation: Between Those Who Permit and Those Who Forbid)
by Shaykh ʿAbd al-Sattār Qudaysh al-Yāfiʿī of Yemen
Al-Bidʿah al-Ḥasanah Aṣl min Uṣūl al-Tashrīʿ (Good Innovation Is One of the Foundations of Legislation)
by Shaykh ʿĪsā al-Ḥimyarī
On the subject of Sunnah and bidʿah I have read articles, treatises and books by renowned early and later scholars of the Arab and non-Arab worlds, as well as by leading contemporary scholars — more than thirty books in all, not counting essays and short treatises. I have read what has been written on this topic by scholars from every circle — Madhhab-following and non-Madhhab, Wahhabi, Salafi, Ikhwani, Madkhali, Sufi and jihadi — across the Arab world, Africa and Turkey, as well as scholars of every school in the Indian subcontinent, examining it all critically through the lens of the sciences of ḥadīth and the verification of fiqh. Among all of these, I found “wisdom, the lost property of the believer” in the four books mentioned above. Alḥamdulillāh, I have found nothing to compare with these four books, and no substitute for them.
These four books can be like the water of life for everyone who is shaken by the “bidʿah, bidʿah!” attacks of the neo-Salafis — at root, Wahhabis — with their catchy, fiqh-free slogan of “authentic ḥadīth only” and their literalist arguments; especially for those who have fallen into inner conflict after studying ḥadīth sciences as commonly taught (I myself studied ʿulūm al-ḥadīth for two years at the Bashundhara Madrasa in Dhaka), who are restless and indecisive, who have been knocked off balance, and who have lost confidence in the practice of their own elders.
And if you want to understand, in the light of the Qurʾān, the Sunnah, fiqh and uṣūl al-fiqh, where our Wahhabi and Salafi brothers go wrong on bidʿah, then hold fast with your molar teeth to the topic-specific books written on this subject by the whole Ghumārī family, cling to the practice handed down through the generations (al-ʿamal al-mutawārath), and keep the community united.
Do not stir up unrest and disorder in society by branding a practice “bidʿah” merely because of the advice or lecture notes of your favourite teacher, shaykh, speaker, scholar, leader or pīr (spiritual guide), without first understanding that established practice skilfully in the light of the Sharīʿah and its principles.
Remember: Sharʿī rulings have many levels and degrees. A single person can create unrest and disorder, yet even a thousand people working for a hundred years may never restore peace and order there. That is why Allah has declared that destroying the unity and peace of the community by sowing turmoil (fitnah) is worse than killing. The Prophet ﷺ established peace in a society of unbelievers, yet we are unable to establish peace in a Muslim society. It seems to me that there are serious shortcomings and errors in our very understanding of the religion.
Throughout the world, the root problem of all those who label the established practices of the Ummah as bidʿah at every turn is a lack of knowledge and maturity in fiqh and uṣūl al-fiqh.
Final word: on the question of bidʿah, it seems to me that the first methodological error in principles (uṣūl and manhaj) came from two great imams:
1. The mujtahid imam, Shaykh al-Islām Ibn Taymiyyah (raḥimahullāh), in “Iqtiḍāʾ al-Ṣirāṭ al-Mustaqīm”;
2. The jurist and legal theorist Imām al-Shāṭibī (raḥimahullāh), in “Kitāb al-Iʿtiṣām”.“
Read these six books, compare and analyse them, and move forward step by step with careful reflection — you will find the truth, inshāʾAllāh. That is all for today; the details can wait for another time. May Allah grant us knowledge of fiqh. Allāh Ḥāfiẓ.
WhatsApp us