Question: Assalāmu ʿalaykum wa raḥmatullāhi wa barakātuh, respected scholar. I am a graphic designer. I create lawful designs and sell them on Adobe Stock, Shutterstock, etc. My problem is that I was working on a single account without breaking any rules, but the marketplace suddenly blocked my account and does not allow me to open another account in my own name. I do this work precisely to earn in a halal way. In this situation, if a member of my family genuinely opens an account in their own name, and with their full permission I upload and work with my own lawful designs there, would that be permissible? I do not want to deceive the marketplace. My main questions are: 1. Can I work on a genuine account in a family member’s name with their permission? 2. Would working this way be deception? 3. Is working this way permissible in the Shariah, and will the earnings be halal? 4. If it is not permissible, what is the alternative?
Wa ʿalaykum as-salām wa raḥmatullāhi wa barakātuh.
Respected sister Samiya Rahat Shrabony, your sincere care for halal earnings and your eagerness to follow the rulings of the Shariah are truly commendable. May Allah the Exalted bless your efforts and expand your provision. In response to your question, a detailed answer is given below in light of the Qur’an, the Sunnah and Hanafi fiqh:
You mention that you do not make any designs contrary to the Shariah. In the Islamic Shariah, remuneration earned through permissible and halal work is entirely halal. Graphic design is skill-based labour. You are creating a halal product (a design/digital asset) and taking a price in exchange for it; in the terminology of fiqh this falls under ‘bayʿ’ (sale) and ‘ijārah’ (a contract for labour) .
“Allah has made trade lawful...”
— (Sūrat al-Baqarah, Āyah 275)Therefore, your main profession and the earnings from it are entirely halal and pure.
In the Islamic Shariah, fulfilling the conditions of a contract is essential. The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said:
“Muslims are bound by their conditions.”
— (Sunan Abī Dāwūd: 3594)Your case, however, is different. You did not knowingly do anything wrong; rather, the marketplace blocked you unjustly (which often happens because of their systems or algorithms). Now, if you open a genuine account in the name of a member of your family, in the eyes of the Shariah this will be treated as ‘wakālah’ (الوكالة — representation) or ‘shirkah’ (الشراكة — partnership) .
The Shariah form will be as follows: That family member (in whose name the account is) is the principal seller. He or she has opened the account following all the marketplace’s rules. And you are his or her designer or supplier. You are transferring ownership of the designs you create to that relative, and he or she is selling them on the marketplace in his or her own name. According to Islamic fiqh this is an entirely lawful commercial method. It involves no deceiving or defrauding of the marketplace, because the marketplace receives exactly the quality and type of design it is seeking.
Sister, the graphic design skill you learned with effort will in no way go to waste. Islam does not needlessly narrow the halal avenues of people’s earnings. Continue your work by having an account opened entirely lawfully in your relative’s name and uploading your halal designs there. The doubt or fear in your mind has no basis in light of the Shariah. May Allah expand your provision.
And Allah the Exalted knows best.
WhatsApp us