Question: As-salāmu ʿalaykum wa raḥmatullāh. I request a detailed fatwa on an issue in light of the reliable works of the Hanafi school.
Description of the incident: Suppose a man behaves improperly with a woman during the day, in a vehicle or at home, while other people are also present — that is, there is no opportunity for them to be alone together, and both are certain that intercourse or zinā is impossible for them there. In this situation the man touches and presses the woman’s breast over the clothes she is wearing, and the woman likewise touches and presses the man’s private part over the clothes he is wearing. At this time madhy (مذي — pre-seminal fluid) is emitted by both, but neither emits manī (مني — semen).
Questions:
1. In the described incident, is ḥurmat al-muṣāharah established according to the Hanafi school?
2. If ḥurmat al-muṣāharah is established, does it become haram for that man to marry the said woman’s daughter?
Wa ʿalaykum as-salām wa raḥmatullāhi wa barakātuh.
Respected brother Shafiullah, the question you have sent concerns a very subtle and sensitive chapter of Hanafi fiqh, called Bāb Ḥurmat al-Muṣāharah (بَابُ حُرْمَةِ الْمُصَاهَرَةِ — the chapter on marriage prohibition arising from affinity or from touching) . In your question you very precisely mention four fiqh elements: (1) the presence of people and the impossibility of intercourse, (2) touching and pressing over clothing, (3) the emission of madhy, and (4) the non-emission of manī.
Below, in order, is a precise analysis of each of your points and the final ruling on both questions, in light of the Qur’an, the Sunnah, the reports (āthār) of the Companions and Successors, and the definitive fiqh principles of the mujtahid imams of the Hanafi school:
First, a theoretical misconception needs to be cleared up. Some think that since touching with desire (الْمَسُّ بِشَهْوَةٍ) creates ḥurmat al-muṣāharah because it is a prelude or means to intercourse (داعية إلى الوطء), then where intercourse or zinā is impossible because people are present, perhaps touching does not establish ḥurmat al-muṣāharah!
The definitive ruling of uṣūl al-fiqh and the Hanafi school is: this idea is entirely wrong. A Shariah ruling revolves not around its ‘ḥikmah’ (underlying wisdom) but around its ‘ʿillah’ or ‘sabab’ (operative cause) (الْحُكْمُ يَدُورُ مَعَ عِلَّتِهِ لَا مَعَ حِكْمَتِهِ). According to Hanafi fiqh, touching with desire is in itself an independent cause. Therefore, even though intercourse is impossible during the day, inside a vehicle or in a crowded place, if touching meeting the conditions of ḥurmat al-muṣāharah takes place, ḥurmat al-muṣāharah is undoubtedly established.
Translation: “As a precautionary ruling, touching with desire has been given the status of intercourse in establishing the prohibition; and neither privacy (khalwah) nor the possibility of intercourse in that sitting is a condition for it.”
— (Badāʾiʿ al-Ṣanāʾiʿ: 2/260; al-Mabsūṭ of al-Sarakhsī: 4/205; Radd al-Muḥtār / Fatāwā Shāmī: 3/32)Your question states that during the touching both emitted ‘madhy’ (the thin, slippery fluid released through arousal), but neither emitted ‘manī’ (ejaculation). In Hanafi fiqh the ruling on this is very clear:
Translation: “The threshold of desire (shahwah) in a man is that his organ becomes erect or its erection increases … and if touching results in the emission of ‘madhy’, the prohibition is established; whereas if ‘manī’ (semen) is emitted, the prohibition is not established.”
— (al-Fatāwā al-ʿĀlamgīriyyah (Hindiyyah): 1/275; al-Baḥr al-Rāʾiq: 3/100; Radd al-Muḥtār: 3/33)Respected questioner, the ruling on your entire incident hinges on a single matter — namely ‘touching over worn clothing’ (الْمَسُّ مِنْ وَرَاءِ الْحَائِلِ).
According to the final fatwa of the Companions ʿAbdullāh ibn Masʿūd and ʿImrān ibn Ḥuṣayn (may Allah be pleased with them), the Successor Imam Ibrāhīm al-Nakhaʿī, and the Hanafi imams Abū Ḥanīfah, Abū Yūsuf and Muḥammad (may Allah have mercy on them) — if there is no direct skin-to-skin contact but a barrier of clothing (ḥāʾil — حَائِل) in between, then feeling the shape or softness of the body part through pressing is not taken into account; the sole criterion is whether the natural warmth of the body (ḥarārat al-badan — حَرَارَةُ الْبَدَنِ) reaches the palm of the hand!
Consider the original Arabic texts and evidence from the foremost works of the Hanafi school:
1. Shaykh al-Islām Burhān al-Dīn al-Marghīnānī (may Allah have mercy on him) states in the world-renowned fiqh work al-Hidāyah:
Translation: “Whoever touches a woman with desire, her mother and her daughter become haram for him … Then, if he touches her over a thick garment through which the warmth of her body does not reach his hand, the prohibition is not established; and if the garment is so thin that the warmth reaches his hand, it is established.”
— (al-Hidāyah with Fatḥ al-Qadīr: 3/220, Faṣl fī al-Muḥarramāt)2. In al-Fatāwā al-ʿĀlamgīriyyah (Hindiyyah) this issue appears even more explicitly:
Translation: “Touching necessitates ḥurmat al-muṣāharah only when there is no garment between them. But if there is a garment between them — and it is so thick that the one touching does not feel the warmth of the one touched — ḥurmat al-muṣāharah is not established, even if this causes the man’s erection (or emission of madhy)! And if the garment is so thin that the warmth of the one touched reaches his hand, it is established; so it is in al-Dhakhīrah. Likewise, if the woman touches the man with desire, exactly the same ruling applies to her touching.”
— (al-Fatāwā al-ʿĀlamgīriyyah (Hindiyyah): 1/275; Tabyīn al-Ḥaqāʾiq of al-Zaylaʿī: 2/106)3. Khātam al-Muḥaqqiqīn ʿAllāmah Ibn ʿĀbidīn al-Shāmī (may Allah have mercy on him) writes in Radd al-Muḥtār (Fatāwā Shāmī):
Translation: “If the barrier (garment) in between prevents the body’s warmth from passing through, ḥurmat al-muṣāharah is not established … even if the size or shape of the body part is felt through pressing (ghamz).”
— (Radd al-Muḥtār ʿalā al-Durr al-Mukhtār [Fatāwā Shāmī]: 3/32, with the text of al-Durr al-Mukhtār)In light of the definitive fiqh evidence above, the final ruling on your Questions 1 and 2 depends on the following two scenarios:
If there were several layers on the woman’s chest (such as a burqa, scarf, dress or undergarment), or such thick clothing that the direct warmth of her skin was not felt on the man’s palm; and at the same time the man was also wearing such thick clothing (such as trousers, pyjamas or several layers) that the direct warmth of his private part did not reach the woman’s palm (only the firmness or softness of the part was felt through pressing, and madhy was emitted) —
Ruling: then, according to the Hanafi school, ‘ḥurmat al-muṣāharah’ has not been established in this case. And since ḥurmat al-muṣāharah is not established, for that man marrying the said woman’s daughter will not be haram; rather, the marriage will be entirely permissible and valid.
But if, in even one of the two touchings (perhaps the woman’s clothing was a single thin layer when the man touched her breast, or the man was wearing a thin lungi or thin trousers when the woman touched and pressed his private part), the clothing was so thin that the natural warmth (ḥarārat al-badan — حَرَارَةُ الْبَدَنِ) of the other person’s skin was clearly felt on the palm through the cloth —
Ruling: then, according to the definitive fatwa of the Hanafi school, ‘ḥurmat al-muṣāharah’ was established immediately. And once ḥurmat al-muṣāharah is established, according to the verse of the Holy Qur’an (وَأُمَّهَاتُ نِسَائِكُمْ وَرَبَائِبُكُمُ اللَّاتِي فِي حُجُورِكُم — Sūrat al-Nisāʾ: 23) and the ruling of Hanafi fiqh, for that man marrying the said woman’s daughter becomes haram (unlawful) forever.
Whether or not ḥurmat al-muṣāharah is established — for a non-maḥram man and woman to put their hands on each other’s intimate parts in this way, press them and cause madhy to be emitted is, in the Islamic Shariah, an extremely vile major sin and ‘zinā of the hand’ (zinā al-yad). In a hadith narrated by Abū Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) in Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim, the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said:
“The two hands also commit zinā, and their zinā is touching and seizing (what is forbidden).” (Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim, Hadith no. 2657)
Therefore both the man and the woman concerned must, with shame before Allah the Exalted, make sincere repentance (tawbah naṣūḥ) and istighfār from the heart, and in future must observe ḥijāb and keep complete distance from each other.
Institutional Disclaimer: This Shariah answer has been given in light of the Qur’an, the Sunnah and Hanafi fiqh, based on the information provided by the questioner. It is intended solely as religious guidance and for one’s conduct with regard to the Hereafter; it may not be used as evidence in any state court or legal dispute.
May Allah the Exalted grant us all the ability to stay safe from Shayṭān’s deception and forbidden contact, and to observe the limits of the Shariah. (Āmīn) And Allah the Exalted knows best.
WhatsApp us