Question: Assalāmu ʿalaykum, respected scholar. A woman had marital relations with her first husband. About 7 months after their last intercourse, a talaq/khulʿ took place between them. Then, without observing the ʿiddah, within a very short time (out of ignorance), that woman married another man. They now have one child. My questions: 1. How long an ʿiddah was obligatory upon her? 2. Will the ʿiddah be considered completed because 7 months had passed, or must it be counted from the day of the talaq? 3. Was the second marriage, contracted before the end of the ʿiddah, valid? 4. What should that woman and the second husband do now? 5. After completing the ʿiddah, may she marry the same person anew? 6. Is there any tawbah or kaffārah for this?
Wa ʿalaykum as-salām wa raḥmatullāhi wa barakātuh.
Respected brother Mizan, this is an extremely sensitive and important masʾalah of Islamic family life. Owing to lack of knowledge, a serious Shariah error has occurred; but alḥamdulillāh, Islam has a Shariah-compliant and well-reasoned solution to every problem. Keeping in mind the future of the child and the family, below are precise, evidence-based answers to your 6 questions, in order, in light of the Qur’an, the Sunnah, consensus and Hanafi fiqh:
In the Islamic Shariah, observing the ʿiddah is farḍ (obligatory) for a woman with whom her husband has had intercourse, after a talaq or khulʿ. And the ʿiddah is always counted from the day of the talaq or separation, not from the day of the last intercourse. Even if there has been no intercourse for 7 months or 7 years, the ʿiddah begins from the day the talaq took effect, verbally or on paper.
“And divorced women shall wait (concerning themselves) for three menstrual periods.”
— (Sūrat al-Baqarah, Āyah 228)The reliable Hanafi fiqh work ‘al-Hidāyah’ states: “In talaq, the ʿiddah begins immediately after the talaq occurs.” (al-Hidāyah: 2/429)
Therefore, from the day of the talaq, the ʿiddah was obligatory upon that woman until three full menstrual cycles (ḥayḍ) had passed. (If pregnant, until delivery.)
In the Islamic Shariah, entering into marriage with another man during the ʿiddah is completely haram, and by ijmāʿ (the consensus of all mujtahids) such a marriage is ‘fāsid’ (invalid/void).
“And do not resolve on the marriage tie until the prescribed term (ʿiddah) is fulfilled.” (Sūrat al-Baqarah: 235)
Therefore, since their marriage took place before the ʿiddah ended, this second marriage of theirs is not valid (ṣaḥīḥ) according to Islamic law.
Since they made this mistake unknowingly (out of ignorance) and also have a child, the Islamic Shariah has a very merciful ruling here, called ‘waṭʾ bi al-shubhah’ (intercourse by mistake or under a doubt) . To safeguard the child’s future, the Islamic Shariah will attribute the child’s paternity to the second husband. The child is not illegitimate at all; he is fully legitimate and will receive legal and Shariah recognition as the second husband’s child.
“Even in a fāsid marriage, the child’s nasab (paternity) is established — to honour the man’s seed and to give the child life in society.”
— (al-Hidāyah, Kitāb al-Nikāḥ; Radd al-Muḥtār)What they must do now: The Shariah’s instruction is that, since the marriage is fāsid, immediate ‘tafrīq’ (separation) between them is wājib. The second husband must say, “I have left you.” And they must immediately stop living together as husband and wife and sharing one bed.
After the separation, because of the fāsid married life spent with this second husband, the woman must observe a new ʿiddah. That is, from the day they separated, the woman must wait for 3 menstrual cycles.
After this ʿiddah is completed, if they wish, they may marry according to the Shariah by fixing a new mahr and with a fresh offer and acceptance (ījāb and qabūl) in the presence of two witnesses. No ḥalālah or anything else is needed for this. Through the new marriage, their married life will become completely halal, inshāʾAllāh.
Marrying during the ʿiddah is a major sin, even if it was done unknowingly. There is no financial ‘kaffārah’ (penalty) for it in the Shariah. However, sincere repentance (tawbah naṣūḥ) and seeking forgiveness (istighfār) are wājib. Both of them should seek Allah’s forgiveness with tears. Allah the Exalted is Most Merciful; He will surely forgive a mistake made out of ignorance, inshāʾAllāh.
May Allah the Exalted ease their problem and restore peace to their family. (Āmīn) And Allah the Exalted knows best.
WhatsApp us