Question: I was married to someone in an Islamic manner in 2015, at the age of 14. I was a minor at the time. After living together for six months, he went abroad. Then in 2018, after I reached maturity, I no longer accepted him and we separated. He has not given me talaq and will not. Legally that marriage did not take place; it took place only Islamically. In 2024 I married someone else, and I am currently with him. My first husband has not given me talaq. How can I be freed from this marriage? I want to know only from the Islamic point of view.
Wa ʿalaykum as-salām wa raḥmatullāhi wa barakātuh.
Sister Oliya Parvin, we sympathise with this critical situation in your life. However, since you wish to know the matter entirely from the “Islamic point of view”, it is very important to set before you the definitive rulings of the Islamic Shariah. In the case you describe, a very serious situation has arisen from the Shariah perspective. Below are the detailed ruling and the way out, in light of the Qur’an, the Sunnah, consensus and Hanafi fiqh:
If a guardian other than the father or paternal grandfather (e.g., a brother or paternal uncle) marries off a girl while she is a minor, then on reaching maturity the girl has the right to dissolve that marriage. In Islamic fiqh this is called ‘khiyār al-bulūgh’ (خيار البلوغ) , the option of maturity.
However, merely moving away from the husband (separation) after reaching maturity does not automatically sever the marital relationship in the Islamic Shariah. The settled fatwa of the Hanafi madhhab is that, to dissolve the marriage by exercising this right, a decree of separation (faskh) must be issued by a judge of a Shariah court or a qāḍī (القاضي).
The famous Hanafi fiqh work ‘al-Hidāyah’ states: “If, after reaching maturity, the girl rejects the marriage and chooses herself, even then the marriage is not dissolved until the qāḍī (judge) decrees separation between them.”
— (al-Hidāyah: 2/315; Fatāwā Shāmī: 3/173)Since in your case the first marriage was not formally annulled (‘faskh’) by any court, qāḍī or mufti board, and the husband has not given any talaq verbally or in writing, in the eyes of the Islamic Shariah your first marriage still fully subsists.
Since your first marriage has not been dissolved in a Shariah-compliant way, in the eyes of the Shariah you are still the wife (a married woman) of the first husband. According to the definitive ruling of the Noble Qur’an, it is completely haram and void for a woman to contract a second marriage while she is the wife of another.
“And (also forbidden to you are) women already married to others… This is the decree of Allah upon you.”
— (Sūrat al-Nisāʾ, Āyah 24)Therefore, the second marriage you contracted in 2024 will be regarded under Islamic law as ‘fāsid’ or void . Even though legally you were considered unmarried, because the previous marriage and marital relations are established in the Shariah, this second marriage is not valid. Your present cohabitation with the second husband is not Shariah-compliant.
Islam is a realistic way of life. If a husband oppresses his wife or refuses to give talaq, Islam does not keep the woman trapped; but the method of release must be in accordance with the Shariah. For your release, it is obligatory to follow the steps below:
Since the first marriage has not been dissolved by the Shariah method (by talaq or faskh), it still subsists. Consequently, the second marriage is void in the eyes of the Shariah. You must immediately separate from the second husband and have the first marriage annulled (‘faskh’) through a Shariah court or mufti board. Then, after completing the ʿiddah, you must marry the present person anew. In this lies your honour and deliverance in this world and the Hereafter.
May Allah the Exalted grant you the tawfīq to understand the right path and to follow the commands of the dīn. (Āmīn)
WhatsApp us