Question: A man sent me money through MFS (mobile financial services). Because the transaction was suspicious, I informed the office. The office said I should hand over the money only after he shows proof of income and after informing them; otherwise I will be in trouble. The man keeps saying he will come but does not. What should I do now? And this money is being used in my shop and is making a profit — if he ever comes, must I give him the money together with the profit, or only the amount owed to him?
Wa ʿalaykum as-salām wa raḥmatullāhi wa barakātuh.
Respected brother Md. Habibur Rahman, your business awareness, honesty and concern to distinguish halal from haram are most commendable. In our time, fraud and hacking-based embezzlement through mobile banking (MFS such as bKash, Nagad, Rocket, etc.) happens frequently. In such a situation, the precaution you took by informing the office is 100% correct from the standpoint of both the Islamic Shariah and state law. Below is a detailed, evidence-based answer to your questions in light of the Qur’an, the Sunnah, consensus and the reliable fiqh of the Hanafi school:
One of the main principles of the Islamic Shariah is that a Muslim must not knowingly put himself in danger, nor be a cause of harm to others. The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said:
“In Islam there is to be neither harming oneself nor harming others.”
— (Sunan Ibn Mājah, Hadith no. 2340; Muwaṭṭaʾ Imām Mālik)Since the transaction is suspicious and the MFS head office has instructed you clearly that you will face legal trouble if you pay without proof of lawful income and their clearance, it is not permissible for you to give that man the money without suitable proof and the office’s permission. Fraud rings often hack other people’s money and cash it out through an agent; later, when the real owner files a case, the agent gets into trouble. So until the office’s conditions are met, the money will remain in your safekeeping.
If that man ever appears in future with valid proof and the office gives clearance, then you need return to him only the ‘principal amount’ he sent; you do not have to give him a single extra taka or any profit.
Evidence and fiqh analysis:
That man made no business contract with you (such as muḍārabah or a partnership). Moreover, if while this money was in use in your shop your business had suffered a loss or the money had been stolen, that man would not have shared in the loss; rather, you would have had to return his full principal from your own pocket (i.e., the entire risk or ‘ḍamān’ of this money was on you).
The definitive principle of Islamic economics is that one who does not bear the business risk is not entitled to the profit either. The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said:
“The right to profit belongs only to the one who bears the risk of loss (ḍamān).”
— (Sunan Abī Dāwūd, Hadith no. 3508; Jāmiʿ al-Tirmidhī, Hadith no. 1285)The consensus of all the imams of the Hanafi school (Imam Abū Ḥanīfah, Imam Abū Yūsuf and Imam Muḥammad, may Allah have mercy on them) is that when someone else’s money is used in one’s own business, the owner of the principal can never claim the profit; for that would be, for him, ‘ribḥ mā lam yuḍman’ (profit without liability, resembling interest).
“By consensus of all the imams, the profit does not belong to the owner of the principal; for it is profit without liability, and the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) forbade profiting from what one does not bear the liability for.”
— (al-Mabsūṭ of al-Sarakhsī: 11/77; Badāʾiʿ al-Ṣanāʾiʿ: 7/148)Here there is a very important and subtle fiqh issue that you need to know:
Our advice: Since money in an MFS account automatically merges with the business balance, you will not be sinful. However, the demand of taqwā and greater purity is— that you do not use for yourself the small estimated profit your shop has made in proportion to that money, but give it in charity (ṣadaqah) to a poor person, and keep an amount of cash equal to that man’s principal set aside or ready.
Since the transaction was suspicious and the man has not returned out of fear because the office asked for proof, the preponderant belief (ظن غالب) is that this is fraudulent money. In this case your course of action is:
“When one despairs of finding the owner, one gives it in charity. Then if the owner ever comes, he is given the choice — either to approve the charity, or (the shopkeeper) pays him the principal.”
— (al-Hidāyah: 2/416, Kitāb al-Luqaṭah; al-Fatāwā al-Hindiyyah: 2/289)May Allah the Exalted grant barakah to your halal business and protect you from all calamities. (Āmīn) And Allah the Exalted knows best.
WhatsApp us