Question: My father is over 70 years old. He is a stroke and heart patient. Over 2 days he pronounced talaq on my mother about 10 times. Now he says he cannot recall what he said. Can he now live with my mother as before? At present they are living separately. We have tried hard to persuade her, but my mother does not want to live with my father under any circumstances. What can we do now? It would be very helpful if you could advise.
Wa ʿalaykum as-salām wa raḥmatullāhi wa barakātuh.
Respected brother Mohammed Shaed Miah, such a family crisis in the twilight years of elderly parents is extremely painful. However, the Islamic Shariah is governed not by human emotion but by definitive rulings. Below is a detailed Shariah solution, in light of Hanafi fiqh, the Qur’an and the Sunnah, regarding your father’s illness, the validity of the talaq and your mother’s present position:
In the Islamic Shariah, a free man holds the right to a maximum of three talaqs. If someone, in anger, pronounces talaq 10 times — or even 100 times — over 2 days, then according to the Shariah a maximum of 3 talaqs (ṭalāq mughallaẓah, the final talaq) take effect upon him. As a result, the wife becomes completely unlawful (ḥarām) for him.
“Then if he divorces her (a third time), she is no longer lawful for him until she marries another husband.”
— (Sūrat al-Baqarah, Āyah 230)Since your father is a stroke patient, it is very important from the fiqh perspective to ascertain his mental soundness (عقل). The principle of Hanafi fiqh is:
“Every talaq is valid except the talaq of the maʿtūh (mentally deficient) and the majnūn (insane).” (Jāmiʿ al-Tirmidhī: 1191)
The question now is whether, at the time he pronounced talaq those 10 times, your father was completely devoid of awareness (insane/delirious) , such that he understood nothing of what he was saying or to whom? Or did he give talaq consciously in a fit of anger, and now, out of regret, says “I do not remember what I said”?
Since, outwardly, your father pronounced talaq 10 times, in the eyes of the Shariah your mother is no longer your father’s lawful wife. That your mother does not want to live with your father under any circumstances — according to the Islamic Shariah, this decision of your mother is 100% correct and an expression of taqwā.
After three talaqs have taken place, for the husband and wife to live together, reside in one house or have intimate relations is completely haram, and an offence equivalent to zinā (fornication). Your mother, out of respect for the ruling of the Shariah, has kept herself away from that unlawful relationship, which is highly commendable.
Since your father pronounced talaq multiple times and later claims “I have forgotten”, according to the ruling of Islamic fiqh their marital relationship has been completely severed.
As their children, your duties now are:
1. Do not in any way force or pressure your mother to go back to your father. If you do so, you will be sinful as those pressuring someone into a haram act.
2. You, the children, should look after, honour and continue the medical care of both your elderly father and your mother equally. But keep the two of them in completely separate rooms or separate residences, so that there is no meeting or intimacy between them in any way.
3. If you have even the slightest doubt about your father’s mental soundness, you may go in person to a knowledgeable mufti in your area, describe your father’s condition and be certain. However, according to the outward description, the talaq has become final.
May Allah the Exalted remove this family crisis of yours and grant everyone the tawfīq to remain steadfast on the Shariah. (Āmīn)
WhatsApp us