Question: As-salāmu ʿalaykum wa raḥmatullāh, respected Mufti. In anger my husband uttered words of talaq to me over the phone. The call lasted about 32 seconds. It seemed to me that within about two seconds he uttered the word talaq several times. I could not hear the first words clearly, but I clearly heard one later word of talaq. At the time of the talaq he was so angry that he smashed his own phone. He thought then that if he spoke of talaq I would be frightened and accept what he said, and that later he could marry me again and set our home right. He had not realised that the Shariah consequences of talaq could be so serious. Since the incident he has been extremely remorseful and weeping. According to him, he now remembers nothing of what happened at the time or before and after it; he only remembers that he divorced me. We informed several muftis, and they said three talaqs have taken effect. But in my husband’s earlier statements there were unintentional mistakes or inconsistencies regarding the sequence of events and some details.
Kindly tell us: 1. What is the rule for determining the Shariah ruling on the basis of the nature of intense anger and the state of one’s understanding? 2. Does not knowing the consequences of talaq affect the ruling? 3. How should the fact that he does not remember what happened before and after be verified? 4. After the earlier muftis’ fatwa, is there room to re-examine the exact words and circumstances? 5. If three talaqs have taken effect, is there any lawful way other than a planned ḥalālah (‘hilla’)? 6. Allah sees the heart; if we repent and want to be together again, what is the ruling?
Wa ʿalaykum as-salām wa raḥmatullāhi wa barakātuh.
Respected sister Tanisha Islam, we express our deep sympathy for this sudden family catastrophe and your emotional anguish. In particular, that you have sought to submit directly to Allah’s ruling — without concealing any truth for your own advantage and without resorting to an unlawful ‘hilla’ — is the mark of a sincere believer. Below is a precise, impartial and detailed analysis of your six questions, in light of the Qur’an, the Sunnah, the consensus of the Companions and the definitive fiqh principles of the mujtahid imams of the Hanafi school:
In determining the ruling on talaq pronounced in anger, the crown of the scholars, ʿAllāmah Ibn ʿĀbidīn al-Shāmī al-Ḥanafī (may Allah have mercy on him), in his famous work Radd al-Muḥtār (Fatāwā Shāmī), divided anger into three levels. Of these, talaq is ineffective only in the anger that fiqh terminology calls ‘madhūsh’ (المدهوش) — complete derangement of the mind — that is, when, through the intensity of anger, a person becomes like one insane and has not the slightest awareness or knowledge of what he is saying or doing.
“What is meant by dahash (derangement) is the loss of reason to the extent that the person does not know what he is uttering.”
— (Radd al-Muḥtār / Fatāwā Shāmī: 3/244)A fiqh assessment of your husband’s mental state (an impartial analysis):
In your question you gave two very important pieces of information:
(a) “He thought then that if he spoke of talaq I would be frightened and accept what he said, and that later he could marry me again and set our home right.”
(b) “He only remembers that he divorced me.”
In the eyes of Islamic jurisprudence, these two facts prove beyond doubt that at the moment of pronouncing talaq your husband was not ‘madhūsh’ or devoid of understanding. For a person whose understanding is lost cannot, at that moment, form future plans or calculations such as “frightening his wife by talaq” and “marrying her again later to set the home right.” Moreover, a truly madhūsh person does not even remember that he gave talaq. Smashing the phone and forgetting the details before and after are signs of intense anger (غضب شديد), but not of insanity or loss of awareness. And according to the definitive fatwa of the Hanafi school, talaq pronounced in intense anger while one’s understanding remains is 100% effective.
The explicit word of talaq (called ‘ṭalāq ṣarīḥ’) is so sensitive that if someone utters it in anger, in jest, or merely to frighten his wife (التخويف والتهديد), talaq still occurs in the eyes of the Shariah. Likewise, not knowing the Shariah ruling or consequence — “that after three talaqs one cannot easily remarry” (الجهل بالحكم) — is no obstacle to talaq taking effect.
The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: “Three matters — their seriousness is serious and their jest is serious (i.e., whatever the intention, they take effect once uttered): 1. marriage, 2. talaq, and 3. rajʿah (taking back one’s wife).”
— (Sunan Abī Dāwūd, Hadith no. 2194; Jāmiʿ al-Tirmidhī, Hadith no. 1184)The authoritative Hanafi works state clearly: “If the husband says that by the explicit word of talaq he only meant to frighten his wife (and did not really intend talaq), talaq still occurs both in the qāḍī’s court and before Allah (diyānatan).”
— (al-Baḥr al-Rāʾiq: 3/278; al-Fatāwā al-Hindiyyah (ʿĀlamgīriyyah): 1/354)The rule of the Islamic Shariah is that muftis give fatwas on the basis of the questioner’s description. If your husband, out of panic or agitation, gave the earlier muftis an incorrect account of the incident (for example, saying without knowing, ‘I gave three talaqs’), then the Shariah allows the fatwa to be reassessed on the basis of the actual incident and the words actually uttered.
There is one very important point in your description: “It seemed to me that within about two seconds he uttered the word talaq several times. I could not hear the first words clearly, but I clearly heard one later word of talaq.”
Here both of you, husband and wife, must — taking Allah as witness and with complete honesty — determine which of the following two situations applies to you:
“If someone doubts the number of talaqs (whether he gave one or three), and he has no preponderant belief, he acts on the lowest number (one talaq).”
— (al-Ashbāh wa al-Naẓāʾir, Ibn Nujaym: p. 62; Radd al-Muḥtār: 3/283)Sister, your sixth question is very sensitive. You said, “Allah sees the heart; if we repent we want to be together again.” Undoubtedly Allah the Exalted sees people’s hearts, and if sincere tawbah is made He will forgive the sin of pronouncing talaq in anger. But tawbah never cancels or revokes a talaq that has already occurred!
In Islam, acts of worship and the forgiveness of sins depend on the intention of the heart, but social rulings such as nikāḥ and talaq take effect on the basis of what is uttered by the tongue. Rukānah (may Allah be pleased with him), after divorcing his wife, came to the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) deeply remorseful and wept. Even seeing his heartache, the Prophet (ﷺ) did not waive the talaq; rather, he asked how many talaqs he had given and gave the Shariah ruling accordingly (Sunan Abī Dāwūd: 2206).
“These are the limits set by Allah, so do not transgress them; and whoever transgresses the limits of Allah — it is they who are the wrongdoers. And if he divorces her (a third time), then she is not lawful to him afterwards until she marries a husband other than him.”
— (Sūrat al-Baqarah, verses 229–230)On planned ḥalālah: Your thinking is entirely correct — the prevalent ‘hilla marriage’, arranged by agreement or plan for a single night, is completely haram in Islam, and the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) cursed it (Sunan al-Tirmidhī: 1120). If three talaqs have truly occurred, there is no other alternative or lawful way in the Shariah to come back together immediately apart from such a planned ḥalālah. Living together after three talaqs merely on the basis of tawbah would, for life, be regarded as ‘zinā’ (fornication) .
May Allah the Exalted grant you steadfastness upon the truth and the best outcome in this difficult trial. (Āmīn) And Allah the Exalted knows best.
WhatsApp us