The ʿUlamāʾ of Every Circle in Bangladesh Have Lost Their Destination and Taken the Wrong Path—Except Whom Allah Wills

A warning from history: while Spain, Baghdad and Bukhara–Samarkand fell, their scholars were consumed by debates on secondary issues. The author compares this with today’s sectarian debates in Bangladesh and urges scholars to recognise the real enemy and the duties of the age.
The ʿUlamāʾ of Every Circle in Bangladesh Have Lost Their Destination and Taken the Wrong Path—Except Whom Allah Wills

The ʿUlamāʾ of Every Circle in Bangladesh Have Lost Their Destination and Taken the Wrong Path—Except Whom Allah Wills

The ʿulamāʾ of every circle in Bangladesh have forgotten to discharge Islam’s obligatory duties according to the time, the circumstances, the identification of the enemy and of the greatest fitnah, and the demands of need. Therefore today, having lost sight of their destination and gone astray, they are leading the Ummah down the path to that abyss (hāwiyah) into whose pit the scholars and students of Spain, of Baghdad, and of Bukhara and Samarkand fell—destroying themselves, and with them three things:
1. Islam
2. The Muslim nation
3. The Muslim lands
Scene 01: Spain;
When Spain was falling, its scholars had become embroiled in disputes over about seventeen issues. Among them was the seasonal quarrel: is tarāwīḥ eight rakʿahs or twenty? Ramadan ends, the quarrel ends. Another such seasonal quarrel was the number of extra takbīrs of ʿĪd. (Such quarrels need no research; rather, a speech or piece of writing produced once is chewed over again every year by oneself or someone of one’s faction, and vomited up every season. And the atmosphere of mercy is polluted with the stench of envy, backbiting, slander and calumny.
The month of worship is turned into a month of quarrelling and mud-slinging, and amid the practice of these futile, satanic deeds Ramadan one day departs in sorrow, while we remain the same wretches we were before.
As a result, Ramadan comes and Ramadan goes, but it brings no change at all to our former envy and malice, slander, backbiting, calumny, quarrelling, abuse, mud-slinging, vindictiveness and vengefulness, or to our attitudes and character.
Is mīlād and qiyām a sunnah or a bidʿah?
Is rafʿ al-yadayn nafl or sunnah—or impermissible? 
Was the dog of the Companions of the Cave black or white?
All of these were the staple diet and main topics of the lessons, writings, sermons, lectures, speeches and debates, the khānqāhs and the religious periodicals of the scholars and students of Spain at that time.
Look today at Bangladesh’s waʿẓ gatherings, teaching circles, khānqāhs, political arena and religious writing: you will see every religious group issuing fatwas and staging displays of its own purity, its being Ahl al-Sunnah, and certificates of Paradise.
 
And against the opposing Muslims and groups, drills are under way—in waʿẓ gatherings, in teaching and in writing—of hurling fatwa-bombs, shells, gunpowder, cannon, mortars and grenades declaring them disbelievers, misguided, innovators, outside Ahl al-Sunnah and people of Hell.
 
In the hands of one group, neither the life, property nor honour of a Muslim of another group is safe; yet in the hands of every group the Hindus, Buddhists, Christians, Qadianis and atheists of this country are safe. Every religious group says: these are dhimmīs, and Islam commands that the rights of dhimmīs be fulfilled. So in various calamities every religious group stands beside them, helps and cooperates with them, and guards their places of worship.
 
But you will not find any religious group standing beside another religious group in its trouble and calamity, extending a helping hand, or guarding its homes and institutions. Rather, at the misfortune of one religious group you will see on the face of another the hideous, grotesque, demonic laughter of the hell-bound Dajjāl, the wish for its destruction, and all-out help and cooperation to atheists, disbelievers and secularists in destroying it. If it is destroyed: great delight and joy, celebration, recitation of ‘Alḥamdulillāh’ and distribution of sweets.
 
And if it is not destroyed, or escapes the danger, you will see the opposing religious group’s regret upon regret. You will hear from their mouths, with abuse: “Doesn’t Allah see this scoundrel? The swine’s offspring survived? The wretch should have died such-and-such a death; the wretch is worse than a Qadiani,” and many other kinds of abuse, curses, imprecations and evil suspicions against Muslims of another group.
 
Yet he himself is a member of an Islamic party, a claimant to establishing the khilāfah, who declares himself, his party leader, his pīr and his elders’ group pure and holy—and what fire of hatred does he nurse in his heart?—what vile, evil plans does he keep in his head about his Muslim brother of the opposing religious group!
 
It is written in their books that on seeing a dhimmī one may exchange greetings and pleasantries, exchange views and chat, take tea and snacks together, and all his rights must be given. 
 
But on seeing a Muslim of the opposing side (misguided and an innovator in his words and interpretation) one may not give salām, because giving salām to an innovator destroys Islam—whereas doing far more than this with a dhimmī disbeliever does not destroy Islam.
 
So if you are a dhimmī disbeliever you will find humanity with them; but if you are a Muslim who has become (in their eyes) an innovator or misguided, you will not find even a shred of humanity with them. To them a disbeliever is someone to be honoured and a Muslim someone to be hated; the dhimmī is a guest, the innovator is fuel for Hell.
 
This, then, is the Islam of the madrasas, scholars and students of every circle in Bangladesh! This is their Islamic education and upbringing! Every religious group in this country cannot tolerate even the shadow, name or scent of another religious group. Each is intoxicated and maddened by a demonic craving to annihilate the others forever. If after this someone still says that it is Pharaoh, Nimrod and the atheists who destroy Islam, I will say this person is mad: in a country that has vengeful partisan Muslims or partisan scholars like us, Satan and the disbelievers take a holiday from the work of destroying Islam.
 
The scholars of Spain were unwilling to give one another a hair’s breadth of concession. Everyone wanted to win. Debates began to be organised everywhere. Everyone would arrive at the venue carrying bundles of books. Some debates took place in palaces, others beneath trees. Whether those trees were banyans, I have not found in history.
 
These debates had one purpose only: to defeat, suppress and crush the opponent in argument; to wound and humiliate the opposing scholars and common folk; and to make one’s own faction win and declare victory—even if by mixing truth and falsehood, through fatwa-mongering, factionalism, sectarianism, fitnah-mongering, shows of strength and muscle, abuse, bluster and fraud. We seek refuge in Allah.
 
But in the end no one could win. Everyone lost. As a punishment upon both parties, Allah imposed upon them the Nebuchadnezzar of the age—King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella. These two slaughtered, burned and drowned in waters, rivers and seas the scholars, students and common people of both groups, and destroyed—along with their cherished bookish lore of debate—all the books of Islam, the Qur’an and the ḥadīth, wiping out Islam and the Muslim nation and paying them their earnings in full, to the last penny, in this very world. The punishment of Hell remains for the Hereafter.
And they teach the scholars, students and common people of later generations what fate befalls those who neglect the obligatory duties of their nation, age and circumstances—what calamity descends upon the destiny of the nation, the country and Islam.
 
—how incompetent, ignorant scholars, muftīs, mufassirs, dāʿīs, leaders, pīrs, elders, khaṭībs, orators, ‘grand debaters’, ‘khaṭīb of the Ummah’, ‘khaṭīb of the age’, ‘sultan of preachers’ and ‘terror of falsehood’ drag destruction, punishment and wrath upon Islam, the Muslim nation and the Muslim lands.
Seven and a half centuries of Muslim rule were crushed in such a way that to this day there is no one there even to utter the name of Allah.

 

Read:

  • 1. History of the Fall of Spain: ʿAlī al-Ṣallābī
  • 2. History of al-Andalus: Rāghib al-Sirjānī
  • 3. Al-ʿAbarāt: Muṣṭafā Luṭfī al-Manfalūṭī
  • 4. Ḥāḍir al-ʿĀlam al-Islāmī: Amīr Shakīb
  • 5. Jahān-e Dīdah: Taqī ʿUthmānī
  • 6. Mādhā Khasira al-ʿĀlam bi-Inḥiṭāṭ al- Muslimīn: al-Nadwī
  • 7. Musalmānon kā ʿUrūj o Zawāl: Saʿīd Akbarābādī
 
Scene 02: Baghdad:
Baghdad, the capital of the Caliphate. The Tatars are sweeping in faster than a cyclone, leaving wasteland wherever they go. The air smells of corpses; one must tread over bodies to walk. There is no one to dig graves. Women are being raped en masse. Children are cut into pieces and stuffed into their parents’ mouths. The limbs of honoured men are cut off and thrust into their own mouths. Birds cannot fly in Baghdad’s sky for the coils of fire and smoke. The river’s water turns red with the blood of the dead—and then black with the ink of the books.
 
On the eve of this catastrophe, the scholars there were engaged among themselves in futile debates over sunnah and mustaḥabb matters of religion. They had no time to rack their brains over confronting the Tatar fitnah. They had no time to see who came and who went. Nor had they time to think about how the country was being run, or who was running it.
 
At that time the scholars were debating in place after place whether crow meat is ḥalāl or ḥarām. It is said they were also holding debating sessions on whether the mīlād is sunnah or nafl.
Just as is going on today in our Bangladesh;
 
  • 01. The Ahl al-Ḥadīth–Ḥanafī debate in Ramgati.
  • 02. The debate on mīlād and qiyām in Jatrabari: Abbasi versus a certain muftī and shaykh al-ḥadīth.
  • 03. The ‘light or clay’ debate: Mawlānā Nurul Islam versus Rezvi.
  • 04. The Ahl al-Ḥadīth–Ḥanafī debate in Jessore: Faraizi versus Muzaffar.
  • 05. The debate on payment for tarāwīḥ: Chishti versus a certain muftī and shaykh al-ḥadīth.
  • 06. The debate on loud dhikr: Mawlānā Nurul Islam versus a certain pīr.
  • 07. The necktie debate: so-and-so versus so-and-so.
  • 08. The debate on collective duʿāʾ in Rangpur: Akramuzzaman Salafi (Ahl al-Ḥadīth) versus the Ḥanafī ʿulamāʾ.
  • 09. The debate at Malibagh Jame Masjid: Ahl al-Ḥadīth versus Ḥanafī.
  • 10. The disputation at Uttarkhan: Ahl al-Ḥadīth versus the Ḥanafī Tahmid.
  • 11. The debate in North Bengal: Ahl al-Ḥadīth versus Shafi the Ḥanafī.
  • 12. Such-and-such debate: Ahl al-Ḥadīth versus Rizwan—and so on and so forth.
  • 13. Abuse and threats of “you swindler!” or “you cheat!” by one Abdur Razzaq against so-and-so.
 
Bundles upon bundles of books are carried to these debates; with piles of books on stools and tables there begins a vile game and spectacle of one Muslim wounding and defeating another. Both groups invoke the Qur’an and Sunnah, ḥadīth, fiqh and Sharīʿah—the masʾalah is merely a signboard.
 
In the words of Qārī Ṭayyib (raḥimahullāh); “Making the masʾalah a signboard to let out the fire within.” No one won these debates in Baghdad either. Nor was anyone supposed to. In such things there is no winning—only losing. That loss belonged to both: both parties lost beneath the feet of the Tatars. A victory of curse, a victory of punishment, a victory of ruin. “Corruption has appeared on land and sea because of what people’s hands have earned.” (Al-Qur’an)
How different are our present-day scholars from the scholars of those two places at that time—in their condition, the harshness of their taste and temperament, the sterility of their thinking, the poverty of their research, the narrow inferiority of their hearts, the unreality of their methods, the incoherence of their work, the shallowness of their planning, the deviation of their aims, the error of their purposes, the monotony and one-sidedness of their speech, writing, study and thought, their unjust partiality to persons and parties, their ʿaṣabiyyah, and the depth of their ignorance and jāhiliyyah?
In the end the Tatars came. They began killing en masse. When their weapons were ruined from so much killing, even if a hundred people remained to be killed, they would order them to lie face-down on the ground and go off to fetch new weapons. A hundred Muslims did not find the courage—did not even feel the urge—to resist this single Tatar soldier. Returning from home with a new weapon, the soldier found the hundred lying face-down on the ground exactly as he had left them. This time he killed all hundred, one by one. All of them bathed in their own blood.
 
Do you see the situation then and the situation now as very different?
Read:
 
1. Qiṣṣat al-Tatār: ʿAlī al-Ṣallābī
2. Al-Tatār: Rāghib al-Sirjānī
3. Al-Ḥurūb al-Ṣalībiyyah: al-Ṣallābī
4. Jahān-e Dīdah
5. Mādhā Khasira al-ʿĀlam
6. Musalmānon kā ʿUrūj
7. The Eagle of Baghdad
Scene 03: Bukhara and Samarkand:
Before the destruction of that land and nation, the scholars there were debating and disputing: in wuḍūʾ, is it sunnah to pour water from the elbow downwards, or from the wrist towards the elbow?
 
Read:
 
1. Ādhār Rāter Bandinī, and others
2. History of Bukhara and Samarkand
3. Islam in Bukhara under Communist Rule
4. History of Islam in Central Asia

Comment here

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


About the author

Name: Najmul Huda Numani
Maktab – Naḥw Mīr: 1996–2000 academic sessions, Darul Uloom Alimpur, Sirajganj.
Hidāyat al-Naḥw: 2001 academic session, Jatrabari Madrasa.
Kāfiyah – Dawrah: 2002–2006 academic sessions, Lalbagh Madrasa.
Advanced Arabic literature: 2006–2008 academic sessions, Darul Maarif, Chattogram.
Advanced research in Islamic law: (Muftī) 2008–2010 academic sessions, Jatrabari Madrasa.
Advanced ḥadīth research: (Muḥaddith) 2010–2012 academic sessions, Bashundhara Madrasa.
Concise tafsīr: Ramadan 2004, Khadimul Islam, Mirpur-13, under Muftī Imran Mazhari (dāmat barakātuhu).
Honours: Asian University of Bangladesh, Department of Islamic Studies. (Ongoing)
Career: From the 2012 academic session to date, by Allah’s mercy, serving as head muftī of the Dār al-Iftāʾ;
One. Jamiul Ulum Islamia, Nikra, Dohar, Dhaka. (Part-time head supervisor of iftāʾ for the first three months)
Two. Markazu Hujjatil Islam, Matuail, Dhaka. (Head supervisor of iftāʾ): 2012 and 2013 academic sessions.
Three. Markazul Quran Bangladesh, Mouchak, Narayanganj. 2014, 2015 and 2016 academic sessions, head muftī of the Dār al-Iftāʾ.
Four. Jamia Mahmudia, Mouchak, Narayanganj: head muftī of iftāʾ for one year, and Shaykh al-Ḥadīth, Jamia Mahmudia, Mouchak.
Five. Markazul Fiqh al-Islami Bangladesh, Mouchak, Narayanganj — three years and ongoing — by Allah’s mercy, founding principal and head muftī.
Khalīfah (authorised successor) of: Shaykh al-Islam Shah Ahmad Shafi (dāmat barakātuhu)
Follow us

Latest YouTube videos

Recent posts

Recent pages