Is mīlād and qiyām a sunnah or a bidʿah?
Is rafʿ al-yadayn nafl or sunnah—or impermissible?
Was the dog of the Companions of the Cave black or white?
All of these were the staple diet and main topics of the lessons, writings, sermons, lectures, speeches and debates, the khānqāhs and the religious periodicals of the scholars and students of Spain at that time.
Look today at Bangladesh’s waʿẓ gatherings, teaching circles, khānqāhs, political arena and religious writing: you will see every religious group issuing fatwas and staging displays of its own purity, its being Ahl al-Sunnah, and certificates of Paradise.
And against the opposing Muslims and groups, drills are under way—in waʿẓ gatherings, in teaching and in writing—of hurling fatwa-bombs, shells, gunpowder, cannon, mortars and grenades declaring them disbelievers, misguided, innovators, outside Ahl al-Sunnah and people of Hell.
In the hands of one group, neither the life, property nor honour of a Muslim of another group is safe; yet in the hands of every group the Hindus, Buddhists, Christians, Qadianis and atheists of this country are safe. Every religious group says: these are dhimmīs, and Islam commands that the rights of dhimmīs be fulfilled. So in various calamities every religious group stands beside them, helps and cooperates with them, and guards their places of worship.
But you will not find any religious group standing beside another religious group in its trouble and calamity, extending a helping hand, or guarding its homes and institutions. Rather, at the misfortune of one religious group you will see on the face of another the hideous, grotesque, demonic laughter of the hell-bound Dajjāl, the wish for its destruction, and all-out help and cooperation to atheists, disbelievers and secularists in destroying it. If it is destroyed: great delight and joy, celebration, recitation of ‘Alḥamdulillāh’ and distribution of sweets.
And if it is not destroyed, or escapes the danger, you will see the opposing religious group’s regret upon regret. You will hear from their mouths, with abuse: “Doesn’t Allah see this scoundrel? The swine’s offspring survived? The wretch should have died such-and-such a death; the wretch is worse than a Qadiani,” and many other kinds of abuse, curses, imprecations and evil suspicions against Muslims of another group.
Yet he himself is a member of an Islamic party, a claimant to establishing the khilāfah, who declares himself, his party leader, his pīr and his elders’ group pure and holy—and what fire of hatred does he nurse in his heart?—what vile, evil plans does he keep in his head about his Muslim brother of the opposing religious group!
It is written in their books that on seeing a dhimmī one may exchange greetings and pleasantries, exchange views and chat, take tea and snacks together, and all his rights must be given.