To: The Respected Chief Mufti (may his blessings endure)
Subject: Regarding the kaffārah (expiation) for fasting.
Problem: Brother Abdul Aziz is a religious man who fasts every year. But this Ramaḍān he deliberately abandoned the fast. When asked why he did not fast, he said: “I have plenty of money, and since fasting is hard for me, after Ramaḍān I will feed 60 poor people (miskīn) two meals each.”
Query: What I wish to know from the respected Chief Mufti is: if he does not fast and feeds 60 poor people two meals each, will his kaffārah not be discharged? I would like to know with evidence. May Allah help you.
Solution: If the above-mentioned Abdul Aziz deliberately does not fast, kaffārah is wājib upon him. According to the guidance found in the Qur’an regarding the kaffārah, his first duty is to free a slave. If he is unable to free a slave, he must fast for 60 consecutive days. And if he cannot fast for 60 days, then comes the third level: feeding 60 poor people two meals each.
Today we see that the practice of slavery has completely come to an end. He must therefore fast for 60 consecutive days. If, despite being able to do so, he does not fast and instead feeds 60 poor people, his kaffārah will certainly not be discharged.
Accordingly, what is best for him is to fast in Ramaḍān. If he does not fast in Ramaḍān and then, after Ramaḍān, adopts the third level of kaffārah while being able to perform the first and second levels, he will certainly not be regarded as having discharged the kaffārah.
al-Bināyah (4/308), al-Fatāwā al-Tātārkhāniyyah (5/18), Fatāwā Dār al-ʿUlūm Deoband (6/447).
A trusted institution for all fatwas, masāʾil and questions and answers online
WhatsApp us