The Four Madhhabs Are Not a Division of the Ummah but Representatives of the Prophet’s ﷺ Varied Practice

Three principles showing why the four madhhabs reflect the Prophet’s ﷺ varied sunnah practice and the multiple meanings of texts—diversity like flowers in one garden or the ten qirāʾāt, not division—while their core creed and definitive rulings are one.
The Four Madhhabs Are Not a Division of the Ummah but Representatives of the Prophet’s ﷺ Varied Practice

The Four Madhhabs Are Not a Division of the Ummah but Representatives of the Prophet’s ﷺ Varied Practice

Three principles;

  • 1. The Prophet ﷺ himself performed many sunnah and mustaḥabb acts in more than one way, for example: the sunnah of placing the hands in prayer, of saying āmīn, of the iqāmah, of the additional takbīrs of ʿĪd, or of rafʿ al-yadayn, and so on. The Prophet ﷺ himself performed these sunnah acts in several ways; now each madhhab practises one of them, and thus, through the combined effort of the four madhhabs, every form of the Prophet’s ﷺ practice remains alive.
  • 2. Many verses or ḥadīths bear the possibility of more than one meaning, and in such cases neither Allah nor His Messenger has specified one particular meaning; so the mujtahids differ, each mujtahid adopting a different meaning—and behind every meaning and interpretation stands another verse or ḥadīth of the Qur’an and Sunnah, or a principle of the Sharīʿah (uṣūl al-sharīʿah).
    In reality, Allah in this way—through the mujtahids—brings into practice all the possible meanings of that verse or ḥadīth, as He wills.
    In the words of Imam al-Suyūṭī: “In this there are many secrets, which none but Allah knows.”
  • 3. Just as Allah and the Prophet ﷺ kept the verses and ḥadīths on usury, fornication, theft, murder and wine clear, univocal and definitive, leaving no room for more than one meaning—so that no difference arose among the scholars and mujtahids on these matters and all are agreed—
    why, likewise, did He not make all the verses and ḥadīths of the two earlier kinds clear, univocal and definitive? Why did He leave them open to more than one meaning, so that the mujtahids blossomed like many different flowers, and differences arose?
    He alone knows best this world of mysteries.

The conclusion drawn from these principles;

  • The differences in interpreting the subsidiary matters of Islamic law—among the four madhhabs and the hundreds of madhhabs that existed before the year 200 AH—are; like a hundred flowers growing together in one garden.
  • In the words of Imam Ibn Taymiyyah (raḥimahullāh) and Imam al-Suyūṭī (raḥimahullāh): “The differences of the mujtahid scholars in interpreting the subsidiary matters of Islam are like the differences between the Sharīʿahs of the earlier prophets.
    Just as many a sum can be worked out by ten methods—this is diversity, not division.
  • And again, like the ten modes of recitation (qirāʾāt) of the Qur’an: the outward pronunciation of words in one qirāʾah does not match another, yet at root the Qur’an of all the reciters is one. This outward difference of pronunciation is not division but diversity—like ten kinds of flowers in one garden.
  • This example too was given by Imam Ibn Taymiyyah (raḥimahullāh), to explain the relationship between the fundamental unity of the four madhhabs and their diversity in the subsidiary matters.
  • The subsidiary rulings of the four madhhabs are diverse in exactly this way; this is not division—which is precisely why the core creed and the definitive rulings of the four madhhabs are one.

Comment here

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


About the author

Name: Najmul Huda Numani
Maktab – Naḥw Mīr: 1996–2000 academic sessions, Darul Uloom Alimpur, Sirajganj.
Hidāyat al-Naḥw: 2001 academic session, Jatrabari Madrasa.
Kāfiyah – Dawrah: 2002–2006 academic sessions, Lalbagh Madrasa.
Advanced Arabic literature: 2006–2008 academic sessions, Darul Maarif, Chattogram.
Advanced research in Islamic law: (Muftī) 2008–2010 academic sessions, Jatrabari Madrasa.
Advanced ḥadīth research: (Muḥaddith) 2010–2012 academic sessions, Bashundhara Madrasa.
Concise tafsīr: Ramadan 2004, Khadimul Islam, Mirpur-13, under Muftī Imran Mazhari (dāmat barakātuhu).
Honours: Asian University of Bangladesh, Department of Islamic Studies. (Ongoing)
Career: From the 2012 academic session to date, by Allah’s mercy, serving as head muftī of the Dār al-Iftāʾ;
One. Jamiul Ulum Islamia, Nikra, Dohar, Dhaka. (Part-time head supervisor of iftāʾ for the first three months)
Two. Markazu Hujjatil Islam, Matuail, Dhaka. (Head supervisor of iftāʾ): 2012 and 2013 academic sessions.
Three. Markazul Quran Bangladesh, Mouchak, Narayanganj. 2014, 2015 and 2016 academic sessions, head muftī of the Dār al-Iftāʾ.
Four. Jamia Mahmudia, Mouchak, Narayanganj: head muftī of iftāʾ for one year, and Shaykh al-Ḥadīth, Jamia Mahmudia, Mouchak.
Five. Markazul Fiqh al-Islami Bangladesh, Mouchak, Narayanganj — three years and ongoing — by Allah’s mercy, founding principal and head muftī.
Khalīfah (authorised successor) of: Shaykh al-Islam Shah Ahmad Shafi (dāmat barakātuhu)
Follow us

Latest YouTube videos

Recent posts

Recent pages