To: The Respected Chief Mufti (may his blessings endure)
Subject: Regarding Ḥajj Badal (proxy Hajj).
Problem: Hajj became due upon a woman, but at that time she had no maḥram, so she had someone perform a Ḥajj Badal on her behalf. Later she found a maḥram, but by then she no longer had the money and means to perform Hajj.
Query: What I wish to know from the respected Mufti is: what is the ruling for this woman?
Solution: In the first scenario mentioned in the question, Hajj had not become farḍ upon her because she had no maḥram; the Ḥajj Badal she had performed in that state will count as nafl (voluntary). In the second scenario, since she does not have the wealth, Hajj does not become farḍ at all.
al-Baḥr al-Rāʾiq (2/538), Fatāwā Ḥaqqāniyyah (4/222), Khayr al-Fatāwā (4/126).
A trusted institution for all fatwas, masāʾil and questions and answers online
WhatsApp us