Question
Assalāmu ʿalaykum, sir. I serve in the armed forces and have completed 12 years of service. When I wished to take voluntary retirement, the officer told me either to retire from the service without any benefits or to continue in service.
They do not want to give me the pension or benefits I am supposed to receive under the government service rules. To obtain my due, I want to take a house-building loan of 10 lakh taka from Trust Bank. But Allah has made interest haram for Muslims, so I do not want to consume interest.
To obtain my pension or due, I will take a loan of 10 lakh taka from Trust Bank for house-building and then apply for the pension. Until they give the pension, I will have to pay monthly instalments with interest. My questions are:
- If I take a loan and pay interest in order to obtain my pension, will it be a sin? And what can I do in a halal way?
- Would it be permissible to take a house-building loan from Trust Bank’s Islamic branch?
- If I take a loan of 10 lakh taka from Trust’s interest-based branch and then deposit that money in an Islamic or any other bank, and — without consuming that profit myself — repay the principal instalments from my salary and pay the interest out of the deposit profit, would that be permissible? I will not consume interest. As soon as I receive the pension I will repay the Trust Bank loan and close the deposit, inshāʾAllāh.
My aim is this: I have a wife and children, and I do not want to violate their rights by leaving the job without a pension. At the same time, I want to consume halal provision and obtain my own due. Please tell me what I should do now.
Bismillāh al-Raḥmān al-Raḥīm
Answer
Respected questioner (military officer, Dhaka Cantonment),
Assalāmu ʿalaykum wa raḥmatullāh.
We commend your long 12 years of service to the country, your sincere eagerness for halal earnings and your aversion to interest. In these times, caring about halal and haram even when claiming one’s own rightful due is a great sign of taqwā. Your awareness of the rights of your wife and children is also commendable. Answers to your questions are given in detail below in light of Hanafi fiqh and the evidence of the Shariah:
Answer to the 1st question: Taking an interest-based loan to obtain a pension, and the halal course
Under your service rules, the pension and other benefits are your rightful and legal entitlement. But resorting to an interest-based loan as a strategy to secure a valid and rightful entitlement is completely impermissible and haram in the Islamic Shariah. According to the rules of the Shariah, taking a haram thing is not permissible except in a life-threatening state of extreme necessity (e.g., when on the verge of death from extreme hunger). Although receiving your pension is very important, from the Shariah perspective it does not reach the level of ‘extreme compulsion’ (iḍṭirār) that would temporarily make permissible something like interest — a major sin and an offence tantamount to war with Allah (Sūrat al-Baqarah: 279).
Shariah evidence:
The Noble Qur’an: Allah the Exalted has declared unequivocally, “Allah has made trade lawful and has forbidden interest.” (Sūrat al-Baqarah: 275)
Hadith: Jābir (may Allah be pleased with him) narrated: “The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) cursed the one who consumes interest, the one who pays it, the one who records the interest contract and its two witnesses, and said: they are all equal (in sin).” (Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim, Hadith no. 1598)
What to do in a halal way:
- Continue making every administrative and legal effort to secure your rights. Apply to the higher authorities or the relevant legal office.
- To meet your financial needs until you receive the pension, try to obtain a ‘qarḍ ḥasan’ (interest-free loan) from relatives or friends.
- Before leaving the job, try to establish an alternative halal source of income or business.
Answer to the 2nd question: Taking a house-building facility from an Islamic branch
It will be permissible to take house-building financing by a Shariah-compliant method from the ‘full-fledged Islamic branch’ of Trust Bank or any other bank.
Explanation: Islamic banks generally do not give direct cash loans for house-building. They invest by the method of ‘shirkat al-milk’ (joint ownership) or ‘diminishing mushārakah’ (diminishing partnership). That is, the bank and the customer jointly own the house, and the customer gradually buys the bank’s share, eventually becoming owner of the whole house.
Condition: That branch must have a reliable ‘Shariah Supervisory Board’, and the contract must be fully Shariah-compliant. If these conditions are met, it is permissible for you to take the house-building facility from there.
Answer to the 3rd question: The proposal to take an interest-based loan, deposit it elsewhere and pay the interest instalments from it
This method you propose is completely impermissible and haram. It is in no way Shariah-compliant. There are several reasons for this:
- Sin in the contract itself: In the eyes of the Shariah, it is not only putting interest money into one’s pocket or paying it out of one’s pocket that is haram; rather, signing or being bound by an interest-based contract (contract of ribā) is itself directly haram. The moment you take a loan from the interest-based branch, you are entering an interest-based contract, which is an accursed act according to the hadith of Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim quoted above.
- Paying off haram with haram: You want to deposit the interest-based loan in another bank and use the profit you receive to pay the interest on the original loan. The principle of Islam is that it is not permissible to free oneself from one haram or sinful act with money earned in a haram way.
- Paying interest: It is true that you are not ‘consuming’ interest, but you are ‘paying’ interest and voluntarily entering an institutional interest contract. In Islam, consuming interest and paying interest are equal offences. Therefore, there is no room in the Shariah to escape the sin of interest by adopting such a strategy.
Conclusion and our advice to you
We understand that you are going through a very difficult situation. But remember: whoever gives up something or endures hardship solely to please Allah and to avoid the haram, Allah grants him something better in its place.
“And whoever fears Allah (adopts taqwā), Allah will make for him a way out, and will provide for him from where he does not expect. And whoever relies upon Allah, then He is sufficient for him.” (Sūrat al-Ṭalāq: 2–3)
So avoid the destructive path of interest and remain steadfast on the halal. Make abundant duʿāʾ to Allah and continue striving to obtain your rights through lawful means. InshāʾAllāh, Allah the Exalted will grant the best outcome for your provision and pension.
May Allah the Exalted grant you the best reward and bless your provision and family. Āmīn.
Answered by,
Mufti Muhsin Uddin
Founder Director and Editor