Ruling on Starting One Surah in Salah and Switching to Another Without Completing It

Islami Sharia Logo
مركز الفقه الإسلامي بنغلاديش
Markazul Fiqh Al-Islami Bangladesh
Markajul Fiqh Al-Islami Bangladesh
Painadi (Donu Haji Road), Mizmizi, Siddhirganj, Narayanganj-1430
Mobile: 01917-655804, 01739-176976
Date: 03-03-1438 AH Ref. No.: F-032 (Album-1)
Question (Istifta)

To: The Honourable Chief Mufti (may his blessings endure)

Subject: Regarding Salah.

Issue: A person, by mistake during Salah, begins one surah and then, without completing it, starts reciting another surah.

Query: I respectfully ask the Honourable Chief Mufti whether sajdah al-sahw (the prostration of forgetfulness) becomes wajib for this person. Kindly answer with evidence. May Allah help you.

— Respectfully submitted by: Md. Rahmatullah, Noakhali.
Answer (Al-Jawab)

Ruling: In the situation described in the question, sajdah al-sahw is not wajib for this person.

References and Evidence (الأدلة الفقهية)

1. Al-Fatawa al-Hindiyyah (1/186): "وإن كان قرأ حرفا من السورة فقرأ سورة أخرى لا سهو عليه"
2. Fatawa Tatarkhaniyyah (2/397): "إذا بدأ أن يقرأ في صلاته سورة، فأخطأ فقرأ سورة أخرى، لا سهو عليه"
3. Bada'i al-Sana'i (1/406): "ولو بدأ أن يقرأ سورة فأخطأ وقرأ غيرها لا سهو عليه"
4. Fatawa Bazzaziyyah (1/29): "قرأ سورة فسبق إلى لسانه أخرى، فقرأ منها حرفا أو آية، فأخطأ وقرأ غيرها لا سهو عليه"
5. Fatawa Darul Uloom Deoband (4/375): "بھول سے کوئی سورت شروع کی پھر دوسری سورت پڑھی تو اس سے سجدہ سہو لازم نہیں"
6. Others:

Khulasat al-Fatawa (1/98), Radd al-Muhtar (1/446), Ahsan al-Fatawa (4/230).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *